Free Homeowner Tool
My House Went to Tax Sale — Is There Money Still Owed to Me?
If your property was sold at a tax sale for more than you owed, the surplus — the amount above the tax debt and costs — is generally still owed back to you, a right reinforced by the Supreme Court's 2023 decision in Tyler v. Hennepin County. Before a sale, a redemption period often lets you reclaim the property. After one, beware "surplus recovery" finders who take a large cut of money that is already legally yours. This tool explains which situation you are in and where to claim through official channels.
What is your situation?
Has a "finder" or recovery company contacted you offering to recover funds for a percentage fee?
Your situation reading
Select your current situation on the left to see what options or rights apply — and where to go to act on them through official channels.
Tyler v. Hennepin County (2023)
The Supreme Court ruled unanimously that governments cannot keep tax-sale surplus above the debt owed. If your property sold for more than the tax debt, that surplus is generally yours — it does not belong to the buyer or the county.
What Tyler v. Hennepin County means for you
In May 2023, the Supreme Court ruled unanimously in Tyler v. Hennepin County that a Minnesota county violated the Constitution's Takings Clause by keeping the full proceeds of a tax sale — including the amount above the debt — and not returning the surplus to the former owner. Geraldine Tyler had a $15,000 tax debt on a condo the county sold for $40,000. The county kept all $40,000. The Court said that was unconstitutional: the $25,000 surplus belonged to her.
What this means nationally: Governments cannot constitutionally pocket equity that exceeds the debt in a tax sale. Former property owners have a Fifth Amendment right to surplus proceeds. This applies across states, though the process for claiming surplus varies by jurisdiction.
What this means in Maryland: Maryland has long provided a surplus claim process through the circuit court that handles the tax-sale proceeding. If the tax-sale buyer paid more than the total debt, former owners (or their heirs) can file a petition to recover the surplus. The timeline and procedures vary by county. A Maryland real estate attorney can walk you through the specific process for your county.
The finder problem: Many former owners are contacted by "surplus recovery" firms shortly after a tax sale, offering to recover the surplus in exchange for 30–50% of the recovery amount. Because the surplus is already legally yours — not in dispute — the process of claiming it through the court is procedurally navigable, often with the help of a real estate attorney at a fraction of the finder's fee. Before signing any agreement with a finder, consult an attorney about the direct claim process.
The redemption period: before the sale is final
In Maryland, a tax-sale purchaser receives a certificate of sale — not immediate title. The former owner typically has a redemption period during which they can reclaim the property by paying the full redemption amount: the delinquent taxes, interest, penalties, and costs paid by the purchaser. Until that redemption period expires and the purchaser receives a deed, the former owner has the right to reclaim the property.
What to do if a sale is pending or just happened: Contact the county tax office immediately for the redemption amount and deadline. In many Maryland counties, the redemption period is at least six months for owner-occupied residential properties, but this varies. A Maryland real estate attorney can review the exact timeline for your county and property type.
Selling during the redemption period: If you cannot pay the redemption amount but the property has significant equity, selling the property during the redemption period — before the purchaser receives a deed — may let you pay off the tax debt from proceeds and keep the remaining equity. The process requires the title issues to be resolved as part of the sale. An experienced Maryland real estate attorney is essential here.
Common questions
What is tax-sale surplus?
Surplus is the amount by which the tax-sale price exceeds the total debt — taxes, penalties, interest, and costs. If a property sells at a tax auction for $180,000 and the total debt was $5,000, the $175,000 difference is surplus. Under Tyler v. Hennepin, that surplus is owed back to the former owner, not kept by the government or the buyer.
What did Tyler v. Hennepin County change?
The 2023 Supreme Court decision held that governments violate the Takings Clause when they keep tax-sale surplus above the debt. Former owners have a constitutional right to that surplus. Many states had already provided claim processes; others have since revised their laws. In Maryland, former owners can petition the circuit court to recover surplus proceeds.
Should I pay a finder to recover surplus?
Be very cautious. Surplus-recovery finders typically charge 30–50% of the recovery — but the surplus is already yours. The claim process involves a court petition, which can often be handled by a Maryland real estate attorney for a fraction of a finder's fee. Before signing any agreement with a finder, consult an attorney about the direct claim process. Many finders rely on former owners not knowing a direct process exists.
What is a redemption period?
A redemption period is a window after a tax sale during which the former owner can reclaim the property by paying the redemption amount — delinquent taxes, interest, penalties, and costs the purchaser paid. In Maryland, the tax-sale purchaser receives a certificate, not immediate title, and the former owner typically has at least six months to redeem (longer in some counties for owner-occupied property). Contact your county tax office or a Maryland attorney for the specific deadline.
Can I still sell the property after a tax sale?
During the redemption period — before the purchaser receives a deed — the former owner may still be able to sell the property if significant equity exists. The sale proceeds would need to satisfy the redemption amount, and the title issues created by the tax sale would need to be resolved through the closing process. This requires a Maryland real estate attorney experienced in tax-sale title issues. After the redemption period expires and the purchaser receives a deed, the former owner no longer has title and cannot sell.
Related tools for distressed property situations
General information only — not legal advice. Tax-sale surplus and redemption rules are state and county-specific. Maryland rules differ from other states. Consult a licensed Maryland real estate attorney before making any decisions. For other states, contact a local attorney familiar with your county's tax-sale process.
If equity still exists and a sale is one of your options
We can map it honestly alongside the others — free, no pressure, no commitment. And we will never take a cut of surplus that is already yours.